Brewer’s guest list according to Michael Dougherty

Brewer’s guest list April 30, 2010
(According to Michael Dougherty, Massapequa Park, NY)

Joseph Brewer-host
Joseph Brewer was living in a beach home owned by his mother at 8 The Fairway, Oak Beach, NY on April 30, 2010. He invited Shannan Gilbert after she finished her work in the city. He spoke with Michael Pak to invite Shannan to his home in Oak Beach. Michael Pak drove Shannan to Brewer’s home in the wee hours of May 1, 2010. Shannan arrived approximately 2am at Brewer’s home on May 1, 2010.

Maxim article:

There was seldom any trouble in the area, and certainly not at this hour, so it was a surprise when 75-year-old Coletti opened the door to find Shannan Gilbert. Petite in stature, with streaked blonde hair, wide, wild eyes, and wearing a tank top, jeans, and a leather jacket, the 23-year-old was obviously disoriented and desperate for some kind of sanctuary. “She seemed like she was drugged out,” Coletti tells Maxim. “She could hardly stand.”

….

…shortly before midnight, she received a response to her Craigslist ad. The appointment was out on Long Island, which was farther than Shannan liked to work—most dates kept her close to the city—but the money was too good to refuse, so she and her driver, Michael Pak, headed out. The drive was uneventful, but Pak later remarked how dark, isolated, and creepy the area was. Around 2 a.m. they arrived at the gate of the Oak Island Beach Association, where the client, Joseph Brewer, was waiting. An out-of-work financial adviser, the 46-year-old Brewer had recently separated from his wife. Neighbors described him as slightly suspicious, skirting association rules. But he’d never caused any real trouble.

What happened next is unclear. According to Pak—who was waiting outside in the SUV—Brewer came out shortly before 5 a.m. seeking help. Inside Pak found Shannan cowering behind a couch, screaming that “they” were trying to kill her. She seemed disoriented, but when Shannan refused Pak’s entreaties to leave with him, the driver returned to the SUV to wait it out.

Within minutes Shannan burst through the door, past Pak and the SUV, and headed straight for the lights of Gus Coletti’s house five doors down.

As Coletti recalls, the police arrived later that morning for a cursory checkup, but it was months before they took up the search in earnest. “It wasn’t until the middle of August that a detective from missing persons knocked on my door and said, ‘We’re looking for Shannan Gilbert, and we would like to know from you what she was wearing,’ ” says Coletti. “So I told them all I knew, and then I asked, ‘Why four months later?’ ”

Coletti statement continued…

Brewer said earlier this week that Gilbert had spent an hour at his home in the early morning hours of May 1, the day she went missing.

—Does Brewer not realize that 2am-5am doesn’t add up to one hour?—

Meanwhile, a man who said he was Gilbert’s driver that day told The Jersey City Journal that her client phoned him and said Gilbert was refusing to leave. The driver, who didn’t want his name used, said he found Gilbert on the phone telling a 911 operator that a man was after her, the newspaper said. She then ran out of the house.

A neighbor said the same woman appeared at his door at around 4:45 a.m.

“I heard screaming at my front door,” said Gustav Coletti. “She was saying, ‘I need help, I need help, they’re after me,”’ Coletti told The Associated Press. He told the woman he was calling the police, but she immediately turned around and fled, he said.

A few moments later, a man in an SUV drove past the house and told Coletti he was looking for the woman. Coletti said the driver, whom he could only describe as Asian, told him they had been at a party and the woman had become upset.

“He took off after and I waited for the police,” he said. That was the last he saw of either.

image
image

image

It was around 3am when Shannan made a call to a CVS with a 24 hour pharmacy located 8 miles from Brewer’s home. My first impression was that this was because CPH had written a prescription and that she was calling to confirm she could fill the prescription. Could this have been a premeditated attempt to frame CPH? Was the pharmacist aware of drug deals taking place in the CVS parking lot? Was Shannan being used to buy pseudophedrine, to be used in the production of crystal meth?

image

image

image

image

image

image

Shannan spent 20 minutes on the phone with MP after the call to CVS. The trip to CVS has been admitted and denied by those seemingly in the know on LISK.com. I lean more toward Shannan leaving the Oak Beach neighborhood than the opposite.

Continue reading

Interview with Fieldnotes-part 1

Jim Jones has been an intergral source of information in this case. I had been so focused on CPH having a hand in all the sock puppetry going on, I was even convinced CPH was the author of Jim Jones’ blog. Phew! I have since come out of my tunnel, and have forged on in search of further information. I cut contacts and decided to get back to the drawing board.

I’m not from the area and haven’t met these people in person, but Jim Jones has. So I decided I would give him a call. I gave him a call at the pizza place he works at; Cherrywood in Wantagh. He was a little busy when I called, and it was understandable since it was almost 6pm on a Wednesday night. He told me to shoot him an email and he’d give me a call as soon as he had a chance. To date, it was the most detailed source of info I’ve gathered on this case.

“Jim Jones” (aka fieldnotes) is a pen name used by Michael Dougherty. He chose that name after the infamous Jim Jones, who was most notable for getting a town full of his followers to drink cyanide-laced Kool-Aid in Guyana. It was a mass suicide of men, women and children who believed Jim Jones was a prophet. I thought the name choice odd and it made me slightly hesitant, but I decided to speak with him anyway.

I wanted to make the most out of our conversation, especially since I wasn’t sure how much time we’d have to talk. I had read most of his blog, but admittedly, when I first read it, I still had my CPH blinders on. I wanted to go into our conversation without any preconceived notions of who Michael Dougherty was and also wanted to assume everyone he interviewed (GC, CPH, HA) was absolutely telling the truth through Michael Dougherty’s blog. So what would I choose as my first question?

WHO was at Brewer’s party on April 30, 2010?

Continue reading

What can be learned through fieldnotes?

Fieldnotes is a fictional character who is also known as Jim Jones. Jim Jones was the name [Billy Bob] gave to CPH when he went with MG during the year anniversary of Shannan’s disappearance. This is why ps149 tells the members of WS that fieldnotes “gives the facts”. Of course ps149 would tell everyone to believe fieldnotes, because both ps149 and fieldnotes are aliases used by CPH to distract and misdirect. Let’s take a closer look at the words he’s chosen. Pay careful attention and read this as if written by the killer himself…

image

image

image

image

image

image

Please check back. I will explore more soon.

Lamb Chops Part Deux

I was going to come up with something clever to say first, but now that I’ve been away from WS for some time, it’s given me some perspective and clarity I didn’t have being immersed in it. So I’m just going to skip being clever and lay it all out.

CPH ALIASES on WS

ps149– the first alias I was aware of. It became clear to me with this post (his comment is the quoted text in the image):

image

He continued to lead me to believe he was CPH with this post:
image
image
Why would ps149 get upset about anyone mentioning CPH’s mother’s name?

Here is another example of ps149 having the answers to questions about CPH:
image

mcme– I had suspicions of mcme as a CPH alias, but it was a fuzzy suspicion at first. Here is an example of one of MANY comments mcme made answering for CPH:

image

mcme claimed to know CPH personally

fieldnotes– aka jjfieldnotes. This was not a clear connection until today. I’m actually rather pissed at myself for letting him dupe me like he did. Sure, there were flags, but did I think CPH had gone to such lengths so early in the investigation? Absolutely not. Could he be so bold? Nah. Could he be so conniving? No way. How is it that fieldnotes is THE ONLY person to interview CPH? Some random blogger is going to get the first exclusive interview from CPH? No friggen way! This was CPH’s finest plant. Fieldnotes actually handed over the information about CPH’s father’s book that truthspider dissected with a fine-toothed comb. The very information that led me to believe that CPH, and CPH alone is LISK. He also had an exclusive interview with Gus Coletti. When Gus is asked about CPH, fieldnotes says that Gus said he wished he was his next door neighbor. ???

The cincher here, it was when I messaged fieldnotes that I believed CPH was the author of the Confessions book and that he was posting on WS as ps149 that I was banned from WS for “sleuthing members” and “spreading rumors”. How I didn’t see this connection until today? Well, that brings me to the next sock puppet…

Dear mysterymom7,

You have received a new private message at Websleuths Crime Sleuthing Community from fieldnotes, entitled “Re: screen shot”.

To read the original version, respond to, or delete this message, you must log in here: http://www.websleuths.com/forums/private.php

This is the message that was sent: ***************

—Quote (Originally by mysterymom7)——Quote (Originally by fieldnotes)——Quote (Originally by mysterymom7)——Quote (Originally by fieldnotes)——Quote (Originally by mysterymom7)——Quote (Originally by fieldnotes)——Quote (Originally by mysterymom7)——Quote (Originally by fieldnotes)——Quote (Originally by mysterymom7)——Quote (Originally by fieldnotes)——Quote (Originally by mysterymom7)—Image: http://i47.tinypic.com/35klkpw.png

I had said, “Hey, ps149, your father’s work of fiction is far superior than yours. IMHO.”

I had said, “I would never attach my name to something that sounds to be written by an under-educated man.”
—End Quote mysterymom7—

I think he’s anti the whole Hackett Conspiracy in general. And again I don’t see Hackett as anything but a red herring but that’s just me. 🙂
—End Quote fieldnotes—

Yeah I mean CPH didn’t write that book I’m personally sure of it. PS 149 may be CPH or someone close to him. Wouldn’t blame if he was. He’s a red herring in my book. Again just MOHO.
—End Quote fieldnotes—

I had said that CPH had lost his license to practice medicine, although I later found out I was wrong about that.
—End Quote mysterymom7—-

Do you think it’s possible CPH told the drifter he would cut him a piece of the book sales to say he wrote it?
—End Quote mysterymom7—

Not a chance. Prob cost more to publish than will make in book sales.
—End Quote fieldnotes—

Any idea why ps149/Hackett would be offended that I was attacking his lack of skills as an author?

If it costs more to publish, is your opinion that the drifter even had the funds to self publish? There’s a language analyst on the threads here that said it’s not consistent with being written by a Puerto Rican Jew.
—End Quote mysterymom7—

I dont know.
—End Quote fieldnotes—

There’s many other reasons why I believe ps149 is CPH. I have a TON of screen shots to support my theory. This ps149 even states he thought it was convenient that the book’s release was in line with the lawsuit on CPH. He also stated he didn’t believe that it was written by the drifter. I know CPH has a propensity to insert himself in the mix of things, but it’s awfully convenient… a little TOO convenient. He also said the W stood for “Websleuther”. If you’d like to see all the screen shots, I’d be more than happy to share.

He’s been stalking me around WS and did in the LISK chat room because I’m the one who started the petition and did the FOIL request. He wants me to stop. —End Quote mysterymom7—

No Im good on the screen shots. I appreciate your passion though.
—End Quote fieldnotes—

Thanks. If you change your mind, just let me know. I’ve been talked about badly by one member of WS who I “met” from MG’s FB group. She’s on a campaign to smear my name through the mud. That’s not why I came to this case. I’ve gotten deep in it and it’s too late to go back. So I will push through to see justice for these victims.
—End Quote mysterymom7—

Ok. I gotya
—End Quote fieldnotes—

[Edit- 2/4/13- I no longer believe the following to be true.]
Precious Dust– aka fine gold aka Feingold. Feingold is yet another person of interest in the minds of some of the websleuthers. Good ol’ websleuthers… handing CPH name after name after name of people to fit into the mold of LISK. It wasn’t just people on WS, LISK.com had their share of people giving TMI and sooooo many sock puppets. Perfect place for LISK CPH to lurk. It is because of Precious Dust that triggered my memory of the night I was banned from WS which enlightened me to fieldnotes being a sock puppet. Behind the scenes (aka in a PM), Precious Dust had told me it was HE who had the email address of the guy from the NY Post who interviewed the “drifter”. He gave me the email address of the NY Post reporter sock puppet. I sent the NY Post reporter sock puppet an email asking if he was SURE that it was the drifter he interviewed who was the author of the Confessions book. I never received an email back from the NY Post reporter sock puppet, but even more interesting… immediately after I sent the email to the NY Post reporter, Precious Dust PM’d me on WS and said, “Wow! That was fast!” I questioned how he would know I had sent the email. He claimed to be talking to the guy in an IM. The kicker: I used my personal email address to send the email, with my REAL NAME attached to it. The same night, I went into the LISK chat room under MY alias (mysterymom7) and someone came on using my REAL NAME as an alias. You got me good, Precious Dust CPH!
[Edit- end- 2/4/12]
(Please check back for screen shots.)

MoonUnderfoot– latest sock puppet. This is a woman, supposedly a “working girl” on Long Island. She somehow stumbled upon WS because her Bat Signal went off ps149 wished a “working girl” would magically appear come on WS to lick his taint confirm that regular “hobbiests” (the code name johns use on web forums) would rather “make love, not war”. Well, go fucking figure that just the person he wished for appeared to confirm that is the case. Of COURSE ps149 would want the members of websleuths to stop trolling where he began his use of sock puppets to talk about the very women he murdered. (I have 3 names already linked to UG that I will reveal in a later post.) It was CPH’s practice forum.

zurcaram– claims to frequently ride his bike down Sheep Lane in Lattingtown, NY. He joined the forum to… ? Well, your guess is as good as mine. It’s just another person giving information veering the members in the direction he wants. Interestingly, Sheep Lane ends at a road named OAK neck BEACH ROAD. Hmmm… coincidence?