Thread: Shannan Gilbert’s family to file lawsuit View Single Post
Originally Posted by [a member that is sharp as a tack]
Mr. PB. I dont think different opinions equal smoke screens. Thats why I said theres a difference between an opinon and an agenda. There is one person I have in mind. NOT YOU. I enjoy reading your post. Along with others.
Well if you are speaking about me I will say that I do have an agenda but it is not what everyone thinks it is. My agenda is simple-
DO NOT CONVICT SOMEONE PUBLICALLY BASED UPON MOSTLY FALSE) RUMORS AND HEARSAY.
In this case, at this particular moment, this agenda = questioning every single rumor and false information circulating about CPH. I don’t know the man, I AM NOT THE MAN, and I don’t even like the man. What I do like is the fair justice that every American deserves. That is what I do like. What I don’t like is how this CPH distraction is getting in the way of finding the real LISK (or killers). So much energy being wasted on trying to hang CPH. So much energy that could (and should) be directed more postively towards finding the real killer(s).
With that I must now state how regardless of what you have been told, there is not one shred of evidence that CPH has ever denied calling MG. There are rumors and hearsay. He DID deny calling MG to speak to her about the halfway house story. HE DID deny ever speaking with SG. He DID NOT deny making the one 4 minute phone call. Those who are spreading those rumors and hearsay are also the same people spreading rumors and hearsay about how CPH has told his neighbors how he treated SG and couldn’t save her.
Just a distracting campaign of rumors and hearsay that seems a bit, well, too organized not to have been started by someone with a vendetta or an agenda to frame CPH.
All this goes back to the 500 pound gorilla in the room that not one person can offer up a reasonable explanation to us to answer;
Why was there never any mention about CPH or his phone call prior to 4/12/11??
MY AGENDA: THE TRUTH. It’s that simple.
Truth: CPH’s mother died SEVENTEEN days after his birth. Complications from the birth? It doesn’t add up.
Truth: CPH’s father wrote a book, The Last Happy Hour, in which he describes being proud of his son’s skills dismembering a lobster at 4 years old, “converting whores”, and bringing his son to Atlantic City where he hired prostitutes. Describing the childhood that created the “whore”-hating man who killed and dismembered prostitutes?
Truth: CPH got his medical degree in 1984. Tina Foglia was dismembered in 1982, with surgical precision.
Truth: CPH has a propensity to take a truth and add his own spin. Newsday covered several stories of just that. The biggest one that comes to mind is the downing of TWA Flight 800. Did it go down in the water near where CPH was living? Yes. Was CPH on the scene? Yes. Did he jump from a helicopter into the fiery water to save the victims? No. CPH’s spin on the truth.
Truth: CPH can be placed near EVERY victim that is linked to the bodies found in Gilgo. He got even more bold after Shannan was last seen alive.
Truth: Shannan’s jacket was seen at the end of Anchor Way. BB witnessed Shannan last. This is basically across the street from CPH’s home.
Truth: Shannan’s belongings were found in CPH’s back yard. The very spot someone on LISK.com circled as the place to look. The person who circled the spot is a neighbor whom CPH had known and had been in court with over a civil disagreement. Not something that would warrant framing CPH for murder.
Truth: CPH denied to the media that he called MG… until MG gave the media the phone records (on April 11, 2011) that proved he did call her.
Truth: April 9, 2011, is the first mention of a “drifter” in the media. Did CPH know that MG had given police the phone records that proved he DID call MG? Did CPH give the reporter at the NY Post the name of the “drifter”? Was this news put out to the media to distract from the news of MG proving that CPH did, in fact, call her?
Truth: All these truths do not prove CPH is guilty of murder. It does, however, make a rational person question CPH’s involvement in this case. All of the truths add up to a lot of circumstances to question and not take the “easy” explanation.
Nothing about this case is black and white. There is a lot of grey area that is hard for a rational person to wrap the mind around. Nothing is as it seems.
I keep my mind open to other possibilities, but if I look at all these truths combined instead of individually, I see that CPH is the most likely person to fit the mold of LISK.